Medical Devices and Healthcare IT

Minimizing Capacitor Leakage Saves Lives

21 June 2018

Sponsored content

Figure 1. Implanted medical devices, such as this pacemaker, undergo intense scrutiny to ensure safety and biocompatibility. Figure 1. Implanted medical devices, such as this pacemaker, undergo intense scrutiny to ensure safety and biocompatibility. Did you know that implantable devices make up the lion’s share (28 percent) of the market — $160 billion worth — for Class III medical devices, according to Global MedTech Market Development? Class III implantable medical devices undergo careful scrutiny by the FDA because they go inside the human body.

Surface-mounted passive components, like solid tantalum capacitors, are among the most critical parts in implantable devices, especially heart defibrillators. Due to the life-or-death nature of these devices, the government has strict regulations on their design and manufacture, requiring manufacturers to take measures to insure highest levels of quality, including full lot traceability, stringent process controls, process change notification mandates and long record retention. Not every manufacturer wants to or is able to participate in this highly regulated business.

The key to meeting these stiff regulations for implantable devices is improving overall system reliability. For capacitors, this means improving reliability and reducing leakage current to its lowest level possible. Leakage and reliability are related and are affected by a number of other issues, which is why it’s helpful to have a basic understanding of tantalum capacitors.

Back to Basics

To appreciate the relationship between current leakage and reliability issues, one must first understand how tantalum capacitors are made. Both the construction and manufacturing details are fairly complex, and vary depending on the type of capacitor, but for now only the necessary attributes of implantable, low-leakage tantalum capacitors need to be considered.

Any capacitor consists of a cathode and an anode separated by a dielectric. What makes tantalum capacitors unique is a small pellet of tantalum that acts as the anode for the capacitor. This anode is covered by an oxide layer that functions as a dielectric, which in turn is surrounded by a conductive MnO2 cathode.

The tantalum pellet looks like a very tiny sponge. Its structure enables a high surface area for the dielectric, which means higher capacitance levels in a much smaller size than other capacitor technologies (see Figure 1).

Figure 2. The dielectric surface area of a tantalum capacitor anode compared to its finished size. Source: AVXFigure 2. The dielectric surface area of a tantalum capacitor anode compared to its finished size. Source: AVX

On the packaging side, there are options for traditional leaded configurations, but more recent technology advancements have seen the introduction of more size-efficient configurations.

Implantable Device Needs

Medical devices differ significantly from their consumer counterparts in terms of reliability. Medical electronics, especially for implantable medical devices, require a high degree of reliability, near-zero defects and long lives. Conversely, the main driver in consumer devices is low cost and high volume.

Life sustaining devices such as defibrillators and pacemakers get their power from non-rechargeable batteries. The lifecycle of these batteries are expected to be 10 years or more. In addition to long life, implantable batteries must be as small and compact as possible, which can greatly limit their energy capacity. Effective power management is the only way to ensure a long battery life in these circumstances.

An important source of power drain in implantable devices comes from current leakage in the capacitors. Current leakages also cause instability and component failure. Thus, controlling leakage maximizes the useful life, ensuring device stability, mitigating component failure and increasing the overall reliability of the device.

The primary culprit behind leakage currents is the presence of impurities in the tantalum capacitor’s dielectric layer. Traditionally, these capacitors were subject to burn-in conditioning and testing to identify parts with an unacceptable level of impurities. Today, statistical screening methods complement burn-in testing to ensure the highest reliability.

Beyond Burn-In

“The tantalum capacitor industry settled on Weibull burn-in and grading for quantifying quality and performance for various applications, not just medical,” explained Kevin Walker, business development manager of medical at AVX. “The Weibull grading process involves an 85C [sic] temperature burn-in cycle at up to 1.5 times the rated voltage.”

The Weibull grading test is an acknowledged technique that allows selection and reliability rating of solid tantalum capacitors. The Weibull burn-in, combined with statistical screening is very helpful to identify and remove components with unacceptable DC leakage (DCL).

DCL is a measure of efficiency in tantalum capacitors, an expression of the loss of power via current leakage through the dielectric. It is a measure of the quality of the dielectric, and thus the integrity of a capacitor. Implantable devices need the lowest leakage possible in order to extend precious battery life as long as possible.

Tantalum capacitor DCL is typically specified in microamps (μA). For example, the DCL of a 10 microfarad (μF), 10 V capacitor would be: 0.01 × 10 μF × 10 V = 1.0 μA

Reliability-sensitive passive component manufacturers use a wide variety of techniques to minimize DCL. To further improve component yields, AVX — a leading manufacturer of advanced electronic components — also implemented more conservative design rules, improved process control at critical manufacturing steps, maverick lot detection, and statistical screening to three-sigma limits to remove non-normal parts from the population, as well as leakage testing at multiple temperatures. Additionally, they restrict changes in materials, manufacturing and testing in order to comply with FDA requirements for effective change control.

The actual distribution of DCL across hundreds of manufacturing lots, compared to the common commercial specification limit of 1.0 μA and a typical medical customer specification limit of 0.250 μA, is shown in Figure 2.

Figure 3. DCL distribution of AVX 10 μf /10 V medical grade capacitors in blue. Source: AVXFigure 3. DCL distribution of AVX 10 μf /10 V medical grade capacitors in blue. Source: AVX

As AVX improved it’s tantalum manufacturing processes over time, defect levels were reduced, and the early life failures assumed by Weibull grading were dramatically decreased. This led the company to explore alternative methods for burn-in testing. They found that a higher temperature of 125° C system burn-in at rated voltage or less, coupled with three-sigma statistical screening, was as effective as Weibull grading at removing failing components. Importantly, this optimized burn-in approach also provides a lower level of DCL and a more consistent distribution of DCL values than can be found elsewhere.

For critical applications such as defibrillators, operating on primary cell power, this low and more consistent distribution of DCL improves overall device predictability, while minimizing battery leakage.

AVX patented the above approach as their “Q-Process,” which incorporated a number of design, process, screening and conditioning enhancements. The Q-Process gives a more normal DCL population with lower probability of component failures and a reduced number of intrinsic dielectric defects within each lot. It has helped to produce medical capacitors with the lowest DCL in the industry.

Summary

Implantable medical devices must be designed and manufactured to maximize the systems operational life. Minimizing tantalum capacitor current leakage is critical to achieving maximum life from the device’s non-rechargeable battery.

AVX has a unique quality process, known as the Q-process, for ensuring the lowest leakage and highest reliability of these critical capacitors. Learn more on the AVX tantalum capacitors web page.



Powered by CR4, the Engineering Community

Discussion – 0 comments

By posting a comment you confirm that you have read and accept our Posting Rules and Terms of Use.
Engineering Newsletter Signup
Get the Engineering360
Stay up to date on:
Features the top stories, latest news, charts, insights and more on the end-to-end electronics value chain.
Advertisement
Weekly Newsletter
Get news, research, and analysis
on the Electronics industry in your
inbox every week - for FREE
Sign up for our FREE eNewsletter
Advertisement
Find Free Electronics Datasheets
Advertisement