Acquired Electronics360

Machinery

Gun Control in a Maker World

20 October 2017

Gun control, and more recently a device called a bump stock, is a hotly debated topic these days — and for good reasons. Criminals don’t care about the laws; they will use whatever they can get, be it illegal or not.

Guns are a physical device typically made of metal, plastic or wood. They require precision engineering to operate correctly, which is usually provided by a licensed gunsmith. More recent manufacturing techniques could make them easier to produce without much skill.

Producing a gun is something that a decent machinist could likely do with a lathe and milling machine, tools that have been around for ages. This is made even easier by the fact that gun parts such as the barrel and stock can be purchased without any checks. Only the part of the gun — called the receiver — that essentially connects all the other parts is considered "the gun" and receives an ID number that can be traced to the owner.

It is currently legal to make your own gun, provided it is not intended for sale or distribution. However, you are not allowed to make guns that would be illegal to purchase otherwise, such as a fully automatic machine gun.

It is also legal to purchase a receiver that has been 80 percent machined and therefore is almost complete. Even though there is 20 percent of machining required to finish it, it is not considered a gun, so it is legal to sell without any checks or serial numbers.

A design for a 3D printed bump stock has been available for download for at least 4 years now that can be printed on a sub-$300 printer in about a day. The legal-at-the-time-of-writing bump stock that enables a semi-automatic weapon to fire in a similar fashion to a fully automatic, is a simple plastic part.

3D Printing in metal is currently very expensive and machines are not typically owned by an individual. As technology improves this may change, as nanoparticle jetting and other technologies could soon enable desktop 3D metal printers. Already, a design for a 3D printed plastic gun made a splash in the news — despiteThe Liberator. Source: Justin Pickard/CC BY-SA 2.0The Liberator. Source: Justin Pickard/CC BY-SA 2.0 the fact that it required an expensive printer and had a limited single shot capability.

Computer numeric controlled (CNC) machines have been around for a while, but the price to buy or make a simple one has become more affordable in recent years. This means that making accurate things out of metal and plastic is becoming affordable for a large range of hobbyists.

As manufacturing technology gets better and more affordable, the "gun question" becomes: Would a law be able to stop a physical device from being made from a relatively simple process?

This question has come up before regarding the counterfeiting of money, in the case of copier and printer technology. Now, if you try to scan or copy currency, the device will detect it and simply not allow you to scan or copy. This detection has been built into the device to thwart would-be criminals. Perhaps we need to make our 3D printers and CNC machines recognize what they are creating, but is that possible? In the case of currency, this detection is possible because specific identifying dimensions and marks are not too difficult to detect. With currency, bills of the same country and denomination are also identical, so there is a limited set of bills to be detected. In the case of guns, there are many different part designs. The detection algorithm would also have to keep up with current laws and receive continuous updates. One additional problem with this is that since many makers choose to build their own 3D printer or put in their own controlling circuit run on open source software, makers with such skills would be able to bypass any algorithm.

At the moment, none of these issues are very significant and perhaps they won’t be for a long time. Perhaps when that time comes we can teach our manufacturing machines to not make weapons. What I do know is that someone who is determined will find a way — legal or not.

To contact the author of this article, email daniel.franklin@ieeeglobalspec.com


Powered by CR4, the Engineering Community

Discussion – 2 comments

By posting a comment you confirm that you have read and accept our Posting Rules and Terms of Use.
Re: Gun Control in a Maker World
#1
2017-Oct-25 12:18 PM

It is said, of attempts to scrub information from the Internet, "The network treats censorship as damage and routes around it."

The same will surely soon be said of gun control. "Makers treat our machines refusing to do our bidding as damage and repair them." It's already visible in the Digital Restrictions Management sphere. Every time someone wants to consume legally obtained content in a manner the producer of that content doesn't want it consumed, DRM is broken faster and faster. Denuvo is a DRM system used on PC games. It used to take years for a newly released Denuvo interfered with game to have its Denuvo shell cracked. Then months. Last month, it took mere weeks. Last week, Denuvo interfered with games were being cracked on the same day they were being released. Denuvo is now deadtech.

The idea that CNC machines and 3D printers will refuse to run the programs put into them because of the mechanical meaning of the parts those programs create is foolish in the extreme and utterly a-historical in basis.

Re: Gun Control in a Maker World
#2
2017-Oct-25 4:01 PM

Great article but following a few threads on various forums homemade CNC 5- axis centers are already making excellent firearms. Fortuneately all the people doing this seem to be representative of the majority of firearms owners in that they are law abiding citizens.

Criminals just are. There are bad people. Perhaps mandatory jail for criminals in possesion of a firearm and more people carrying with a civil duty to stop crime would be a solution. Having said that as most people are pretty stupid, don't evaluate situations before reacting and have screwy 'morals' and 'values'. England has strict firearms laws, they still have a problem with illegal firearms.

Pandora's Box has been opened and there is no going back.

Engineering Newsletter Signup
Get the Engineering360
Stay up to date on:
Features the top stories, latest news, charts, insights and more on the end-to-end electronics value chain.
Advertisement
Weekly Newsletter
Get news, research, and analysis
on the Electronics industry in your
inbox every week - for FREE
Sign up for our FREE eNewsletter
Advertisement

CALENDAR OF EVENTS

Date Event Location
30 Nov-01 Dec 2017 Helsinki, Finland
23-27 Apr 2018 Oklahoma City, Oklahoma
18-22 Jun 2018 Honolulu, Hawaii
Find Free Electronics Datasheets
Advertisement